*A Texas man’s scheduled execution has ignited a fierce national debate over whether rap lyrics belong in a courtroom — and some of the biggest names in hip-hop are making their voices heard at the highest level of the American justice system, USA Today reports.
James Broadnax, 37, faces lethal injection on April 30 for the 2008 deaths of Stephen Swan and Matthew Butler, Christian music producers who were killed during a robbery near their studio in the Dallas-area city of Garland. Broadnax was 19 at the time and was convicted the following year by a predominantly white jury. His cousin and co-defendant, Demarius Cummings, now serving life without parole, recently claimed he was the actual shooter — stating that Broadnax took responsibility believing his clean record would result in a lighter sentence.
The sentencing phase of the trial became the focal point of controversy. Although the rap lyrics Broadnax had produced in notebooks had no bearing on the guilt verdict, prosecutors brought those 40 handwritten pages before the jury during punishment deliberations. Jurors requested to review the material twice before voting for death over a life sentence. Defense attorneys argue that outcome turned Broadnax’s “artistic expression into a death warrant.”
Travis Scott, Killer Mike, Young Thug, and T.I. have each submitted friend-of-the-court briefs to the U.S. Supreme Court. Scott’s filing argues that prosecutors penalized Broadnax specifically for creating “gangster rap,” which the brief calls “a categorical and straightforwardly unconstitutional content-based penalty on rap music as a form of expression.”
Scroll to continue reading
Killer Mike’s concurrent brief argues the proceedings were tainted by racial prejudice, stating the case “exemplifies the racial prejudice that infects a criminal proceeding when the State uses a defendant’s rap lyrics to capitalize on anti-rap bias, the misinterpretation of rap lyrics, and anti-Black bias triggered by rap music.”
Broadnax’s attorneys filed a Writ of Certiorari in February seeking Supreme Court review. Dallas County prosecutors have dismissed those arguments, defending the lyrics as evidence of gang affiliation and Broadnax’s “cold, flippant attitude toward the murders.”
“We firmly believe that the full and complete case for James Broadnax has not been heard in a court of law and that carrying out his execution as scheduled on April 30 would be an irreparable legal and moral mistake,” Broadnax’s attorneys said in a statement. “James Broadnax’s legal team and his growing body of supporters will continue to fight on his behalf.”
MORE NEWS ON EURWEB.COM: Rappers Petition Supreme Court Over Lyrics in Death Sentence Case
Sign up for our Free daily newsletter HERE
